Fantasticaa!
Don't you wish you could enjoy your job this way? :-)
翻訳で失われる
If you are the kind that sometimes feels lonely in a crowd, finds somewhat unintelligible the idioms of all kinds of relationships, sometimes dissolve spontaneously into tears when no one is looking, into your visor or onto your pillow, are continuously unsure of the hands dealt out to you, have had the experience to understand that some of the best times in life are tiny and fleeting and irretrievable, for whom time hangs interminably with hostility and can be filled with a hundred different actions but you choose to stuff them with a million irreconciliable thoughts, curled up and seeking solace in the one person you're both stuck with and can rely on, i.e. yourself; if you are this kind, then perhaps you will like to see Lost in Translation.The title of this post, if you haven't guessed it yet, is the Japanese translation of the phrase "Lost in Translation" according to the WorldLingo service . If you happen to have settings in your browser that don't render the title correctly and make it look like "?????", then you know what happened, right? It got "lost in translation".
Even Rahul
In a measure of how pervasive it has got, the stand-in Indian captain (in his post-toss interview with Ian Chappell) said there was a "feel good factor" among his team. Considering that Rahul Dravid is usually very politically correct and is very judicious in his choice of words, this must have been an unconscious use of a phrase that can be heard several times during the day in all sorts of conversations. Like "nothing official about it", another triumph for the copywriter.Thoughts on the AE/Yuva soundtrack
Disclaimer: I haven't heard this album (Aaytha Ezhuthu that is) from the CD, only from decent quality .rms and mp3s. This is not a review, so it doesn't matter. Plus, I don't have a CD player that can play the copy protected CD, so ironically it prevents me from buying it - can't help that.It doesn't help that seven times in the past the combination of Mani Ratnam, A.R.Rahman and Vairamuthu have delivered some of the best soundtracks in the last 15 years. Their music has had both commercial and critical success - with album sales and National Awards testament to them. So when the latest offering is due, one can't help but feel excited about the prospect of their 8th collection. For me, Aaytha Ezhuthu ranks #8 on that list. They have covered a lot of musical ground in the past, so I don't quite agree with the appeal for not comparing this to the earlier ones. It is inevitable, and I don't see it as a negative comment.
Initial disappointment has given way to a certain making of peace with it. The songs are definitely not outstanding among all the many ones done in the past. However, there is quite a bit to relish from it too. I don't think Rahman is floundering, for Meenaxi showed that the depth and range is still there. Since I haven't seen AE, I don't know if the songs fit the film well.
It has been quite interesting to see how the fan communities react to each release. "Fan-aticism"is an oft-discussed topic among my social circle, particularly w.r.t to music - the R.D.Burman groups and shows give me a chance for more objective observation. In this case, I'm a fan struggling to retain my objectivity. The fact that I'm a fan impels me to give all new ARR albums a greater chance to hook me than I would any other recent offering. I must say that Rahman albums of late haven't reached out and grabbed the populace by their shirtcollars, but that's not to say the output has suffered. It has changed, altered, evolved. I still don't like the excessive rap-based trend in the songs, but to some extent the subject matter of these films have also been responsible.
I've also noticed that the first reaction of fans to any criticism is to get defensive and/or aggressive about it. It's hard to be unbiased - there's nothing wrong in having a slant towards it, but a good appreciator of anything should be able to work for himself what the limits of it are. I really find it irritating when "fans" get so possessive about their idols, who themselves are smart enough to understand what has gone wrong and are unwilling to lend an ear to any dissenter. Anu Malik is one person who carries a persecution complex around instead of reflecting on reality, these fans are no different according to me.
That slight tirade over. Coming to this album, I don't completely agree with it being labeled a "techno/trance" album - another generalization that will do it no good. There are six tracks, of which only one would probably a trance track (I'm no authority on these things). Fanaah is quite interesting in that though it is apparently set in a discotheque, it gets very philosophical and profound about love and has an extended sargam (is that what I can call it?) from the music director. It's very western and urban, and Vivek Oberoi & Ms. Kapoor would be quite suitable in it - you can already appreciate the wisdom of the casting. Fanaah is a cool Urdu word to be used here, and Rahman has expounded on its significance in interviews.
Dol Dol is more instrumental (the "voice" instrument included) than song. This album was supposed to be just a soundtrack for this originally songless film. This track fits easily into that mould.
SanDa Kozhi is sung by Madhushree (Naina Milaike), an interesting choice. Her diction is suspect to me, but I am confused since she did get some of the tough words right on some occasions and different on others. This is easily a trademark ARR song, and the folkish crooning by him in the middle is excellent, and in retrospect, well worth the album.
Goodbye NaNbaa is one of those that grew quietly from a negative view to an appreciative one. I liked the changes in tone and tempo, in particular the hushed singing of Sunita Sarathy. The male portions are crowded with a lot of percussions at times. The slow, jazzy portions towards the end fit into the structure of the song, I felt.
The beginning of Jana GaNa Mana heightens one's expectations, so the rest of the song was a letdown for me. This is a lyrical beauty and the mood set in the beginning embellishes them greatly, but somehow, I got the feeling of incompleteness overall.
I really dislike the Adnan Sami song - Nenjam Ellaam - for me it's a nothing song. After a while, here's an ARR song that I can't even listen to and disregard - it has no flavour in it for me. I really wish ARR would stop using people uncomfortable with singing in Tamil. There's a distinct labouring effort seen in their output that seems to cut into their aural expressions. Gone are the days when they used to be cute. Haven't heard SPB in ages.
Yuva for me was painful to hear for the first time. Except for Khudaa Haafiz and Kabhi Neem (both in parts), I found the others embarassing at times. The critical difference between the two versions are the lyrics. Clearly, the Tamil one came before, and Mehboob hasn't been able to fill in the Vairamuthu blanks. Some of the Hindi lyrics are so bad that they distract whatever flavour is available in the music. Vairamuthu on the other hand has done a marvellous job. Except for Goodbye NaNbaa where I felt the words were sometimes a little trite and too modern, the rest are great, especially the politically idealistic Jana GaNa ("Oh Rulers of the people's minds, think of them"), in exploring the mystical dimensions of love in Fanaah ("The body is the wick, love the flame") and the mollifying yet scolding words of SaNda Kozhi. The Hindi version of Jana GaNa Mana merely comes out as a weak lookalike of Mammaiya Kero (Arjun - R.D.Burman), just because of the lyrics.
I really wish Mani Ratnam would've gone ahead with his original convictions of using just a background score. To me, specific portions of most of the songs seem to be outstanding, but the rest of the pieces don't sustain it. I'm just speculating here, but could it be that that's how these started off life, and were later extended? I feel the album has ended up somewhere between a great background score and an average album, definitely by past standards. Perhaps the film (for a change) will heighten the experience of the songs. The fans will end up loving it, whether in parts or in totality. The Tamil lyrics are the biggest plus in AE, and can alter the perception of the tracks. I don't the masses are going to make a fuss about it, the album is different from Bollywoodian tastes for sure. Will now move my attention to watching some trademark Mani Ratnam [choreo|cinemato]graphy for these songs.
AE/Yuva Trailer Watch - II
The Hindi trailers are now featuring some of the songs - first Khuda Haafiz and now Kabhi Neem. The Tamil trailers are still in the triad establishing the characters of Surya, Siddharth and Madhavan. For those who will be following and watching both versions, the comparisons between the Tamil & Hindi casts will be very interesting to follow. The dialogues and scenes evidenced so far are almost identical. Madhavan (in his third different "look" for a MR movie) sports this drastic haircut, which started me thinking on how Tamil and the other South Indian film actors, (not to be called "South" - you idiotic media people) have never shied away from changing as required. Contrast this with a unkempt Abhishek B. , the Hindi counterpart of Madhavan in Yuva which is as far as he would go I guess. Especially as it was rumoured that he didn't want to play a negative role in the first place.
Ayutha Ezhuthu/Yuva Watch [updated]
The trailers are out... First of all, the logo is (pardon the descent into teenybopper slang) way cool! (See it at the official website for Ayutha Ezhuthu). In keeping with my general impressions of the names of the Hindi & Tamil versions, the logo for Yuva is just about ok.Anti on some of the rumours linking AE & the Oscar nominated City of God
A note on the trailers:
Trailers for Mani Ratnam films create quite a buzz usually, and the songs usually herald the film on TV (Dil Se for example). Not this time. They've chosen to establish the characters of the three male (stars and) protagonists. Ajay Devgan is the the man with the ideology, with a montage of jail, leadership and protest. Vivek Oberoi will probably in the center of the mental conflict, and is portrayed as a normal guy wanting to leave for the US. Abhishek Bachchan looks like being the negative pole of the film - wanting money and power, and with a unkempt look. I'm a known Kareena Kapoor baiter, but I must be fair and say that she looks quite pretty in the scenes so far, and the wardrobe looks elegant - trust Mani saar to get it right. >Rani Mukherjee is a flash here and there opposite the Small B (shades of Antara Mali in Company). No idea how the three lines intersect.
The trailers have chosen to establish the "intellectual" vibe of the film. And there is one more subliminal message: Calcutta looms not far behind in all the shots, clearly an important part of the movie. Adds to the buzz. The last metro to form the backdrop of a Ratnam film after Madras, Bombay & Delhi. Snatches of very Western sounding, clearly Rahman-esque music linger in the audioscape. More buzz. Haven't seen any Ayutha Ezhuthu trailers yet.
I really don't believe this movie will do well commercially all over India - sadly, films these days have been bracketed into "metro multiplex movies" too easily. So if it is a cultural partition, I'm clearly on the side that feels excited by these trailers. I have my doubts about the histrionic abilities of Messrs. Kapoor, Trisha, Siddharth & Deol and whether Oberoi & Bachchan can do it here. But Mani saar got Simran to dazzle in KM, didn't he? But just putting Ratnam, Rahman, Vairamuthu on the same line here sends a tingle down the spine. Add the rest of the names in Tamil & Hindi and ... can you blame us all for hyping this one? A man who can have it and doesn't want it, a man who would like to have it, and a man who wants it and can't have it - is that what the trailers want to tell us?
The next steps in Blog Tools
Follow an interesting discussion on A vision for the next generation of blogging tools here. The comments there have already thrown out a number of extremely thought provoking ideas.My own personal yearning right now is for the ability to index, organize and group my blog posts based on content, areas and perhaps intended audience. Right now, I'm organizing my archives to do part of this albeit manually. Wouldn't it be great to have your post automatically added into a collection of your previous blogs on "Films" or "Cricket"?
The good Doctor(s) is(are) back
Star World has a new season of (probably my most favourite comedy series) Frasier. Quite appropriately, the cracker of an episode featured a profusion of Oedipal urges and typically sardonic wit. No Eddie in sight, but Rita Wilson (more famously known as Mrs. Tom Hanks) was a guest star.
This was our world once
The Pune pages of the Indian Express feature a small write-up on Dear ol' Boat Club a.k.a the nerve centre of COEP. Of course, there's no mention of the Quiz Club, you woud be hard pressed to find any resident COEPian who professed any knowledge of that.Life back then wasn't so different
Was good to see this one again, this time in the pages of Eric Steven Raymond's The Art of Unix Programming.It's a well-known fact that computing devices such as the abacus were invented thousands of years ago. But it's not well known that the first use of a common computer protocol occurred in the Old Testament. This, of course, was when Moses aborted the Egyptians' process with a control-sea.-- Tom Galloway, rec.arts.comics, February 1992
A LOI rule suggestion
We know that bowling sides are sometimes reduced to being punching bags for batsmen who wield the 15-over rule, only 1 bouncer per over rules etc. to rein in the spinners and seamers. I've always had a small improvement in mind in the ODI rules that I think can address this imbalance. I find it a little unfair that a batting side has the opportunity to use an in-form batsman for as much of the 50 overs as possible, while the bowling side can give its in-form bowlers only upto 10 overs each. Additionally, with the balance of teams tilting towards a buffer batsman, the bowling side always has a weak 5th/6th bowler that is targeted by the opposing batsman; this only causes a spiralling effect in the imbalance. I clearly rememebr a match between India & Australia in the tri-series Down Under in 1999 (the third team being Pakistan). I think it was at Sydney, where the conditions were exceptionally favourable for the seamers. India was out for a low score, but the Aussies got into trouble straightaway with Srinath bowling grenades and bombs in a straight 10-over spell. The fact that the Aussies were able to play out Srinath's 10 and that Symonds could give the other batsman (SRW or Bevan?) some support meant that they won.My suggestion to allow the bowling side the option of allowing atleast one bowler to have a quota of upto 12 or 13 overs. You want to see the best batsmen of one side take on the best bowlers of the others, not them wait for those 10 overs and bash the 5th bowler up. By allowing an increased quota (it could even be 11/12 overs each for two bowlers perhaps) would give beleagured captains an fair chance to overcome situations where one other bowler is having an off day. If Srinath had bowled a couple of more overs that day, India might've won!
I look at it as easing some of the restrictive trade practices in cricket :-).
Faux News - II
Boring vandals at it again!
From our Culture correspondent in Pune
In yet another protest from the morality police that seems to have estabished an outpost in the old cultural city of Pune, activists of yet another organization have threatened agitations and even vandalism against what they claim to be "lowering of standards in the Indian society".
In a press conference, the spokesman of the hitherto unknown "Rambhau Anna's Moral Bunch Of Gentlemans", also known as the RAMBO-G Brigade, Mr. Gaurang Zebadkar protested the recent decision of baker-turned-director Essel "Buns" Ali to cast renegade star Prem Kahn and star-child Premi K. Dev Annie in the title roles of his upcoming multi-million historical magnum opus Budgie Row & Mist-Annie. Mr. Zebadkar claimed that Maharastrian self-pride could not accept such a mis-casting. He said that these two Bollywood stars in particular epitomised the growing rot in Indian culture. Ms. Asmita Gujarati, leader of the women's wing of the Brigade and well-known garments manufacturer, accused the stars of polluting many young minds into following skimpy fashion trends, directly affecting the livelihood of several cotton mill workers. The RAMBO-G Brigade laid out a set of 6 demands, including the dropping of either one of the lead actors and replacing him or her with a local Maharastrian performer, in keeping with the "sons-of-the-soil" policy adopted by the organization. Taking a tough stand, Ms. Gujarati said "We've not worn bangles to see some outsiders make films on our heroes and misrepresent our culture". Both Mr. Zebadkar & Ms. Gujarati refused to comment on whether they had read the film's script to ascertain its validity.
This correspondent was unable to reach Mr. Essel "Buns" Ali, but his secretary informed us that Mr. Ali had no reaction to give to the press on this matter. Mr. Ali is said to be in South Africa scouting locations for his film. This is not the first time that the one-time baker has had to face criticisms over his movies. It may be recalled that the Alcoholics Anonymous group had been up in arms over Mr. Ali's last venture. Ms. Dev Annie was also unavailable for comment, and is said to be wrapping up work on her film Chum Maali - The Friendship of a Gardener. However, an irate Mr. Kahn did react strongly against his detractors and dismissed all criticisms that he was not the right choice to play the role. Friends of the actor say that he almost jumped out of his clothes in indignation when he heard the RAMBO-G Brigade spokesman claim that Kahn didn't even know how to speak Marathi. The same sources refused to confirm if Kahn's exact words were "Tya.nchaa Ai**** Du*** **** ***".
Budgie Row & Mist-Annie is a classic early 20th-century tale of love and sacrifice. Buddhijeevi "Budgie" Row, a seller of birds, rescued young Annie in a daring bid in the mist and rain from Hash Wednesday Chowk, (the flesh-trade bazaar of ancient Pune named after a notorious English opium trader who established it) where she had been forced to live by an evil uncle. In time, they became the leading lights of Puneri society and established a famous hotel called The Saturday Sambaar (some say it was by virtue of their close relationship with the then Vice President). Mr. "Buns" Ali has sought to portray their tempestuous courtship and happy marriage on screen as a tribute to his memories of the dahi vada during his college days at The Saturday Sambaar. He plans to release it on Valentine's Day 2005, a move that has further irked the militant members of the Brigade who have threatened to burn down The Saturday Sambaar in protest. It still remains to be seen which of the two parties will blink first, clearly this is a game of blinkmanship.
Q: What did Fardeen Khan have to say when he found Pepsi was in trouble over the pesticides scam?
A: "It always happens to me. If I'm with Pepsi, this happens. When I tried Coke, the police got after me. Damn!"
Contributed by Faux Muddler
This is a subscriber-paid newspaper only. If you don't have a valid subscription,
please close this browser window immediately or else a faux-virus will be installed
on your C: drive.
Click here for a free look at an earlier edition.
ROTK revisited
I have been reviewing my reactions to LOTR - ROTK and have a few more points to offer. The principal reason why I stayed away from reading the books was to find out for myself how that affects the way how I react to the filmed version. In most cases where a film is based on a well-known book, I know a bit about the plot, but in the case of LOTR, I was completely ignorant of it. It was a very interesting exercise in forming an opinion of film adaptations and the difficulties in doing them - David Lean's biography (a BCL copy of which I had read a few years ago) had dwelt on the many pitfalls accompanying screen adaptations.Most LOTR fans (those who've read the books) I know are primarily excited in seeing how the Jackson trilogy brings to screen Tolkien's grand and complex vision. They are already aware of the plot, so they can set aside any anxiety in that regard. This doesn't not hold for those who haven't read the books and they wonder what else is in store ahead. Unfortunately, I think the story in the last segment is very inevitable and everyone recognises it - it is, after all, a straightforward tale of good versus evil at its core. Even within that limitation, the grey areas as signified by Gollum/Smeagol do provide an excellent counterpoint to the plucky Hobbits and the conventional bravery of the other heroes. I think the film's plot would never have had any surprises - in a book, this predictability can be overcome with the elements of wordsmithy, character development etc without worrying too much about the length. In a film, this has to be done with the elements of locales, acting, battle scenes et al, which do need the viewer to be looking out for them. Those viewers who aren't watching out for the development of the plot can do this better, and especially those who must have read and marvelled at Tolkien's imaginative settings and character sketches, which apparently Jackson has done justice to on screen. But for viewers like me, it cannot be achieved on the first viewing where the story is always paramount - there is such a profusion of participants that it is hard work keeping up with the multitude of interwoven threads in the first place.
There is absolutely no disputing the top-notch cinematography, locales, special effects. There are some glorious cinematic moments too, some of the battle sequences, the grateful bowing of everyone to the Hobbits, the opening with a brief flashback to Smeagol are all well-done. But I still carry my criticisms of the unravelling of the plot for the last edition, and hence my opposition for a Best Picture nod for this particular film taken alone, though everyone knows it is more in recognition for all the three etc. I think the last two editions couldn't carry that section of the audience that had not read the books, and while that may be excellent motivation to read them, as a cinematic endeavour, it hasn't been quite that successful. LOTR-FOTR did a marvellous job (as one commentor rightly pointed out) in introducing us to the world of Middle Earth, the context of the conflicts, the various traits of the different races and unveiled this grand canvas that previously lived in the minds of the LOTR fans. The Two Towers, but for the Gollum development, was the weakest of the three to my mind. I'm sure a lot of details didn't make it to the screenplay from the books, and I still feel some of the last scenes (those that book fans, on the contrary, may feel aggrieved that they had been only fleetingly referred to in the film) didn't add much cinematic value and only succeeded in diluting the end to an intense plot.
I'm quite happy that my decision to stay away from the books has helped me in thinking about these things from an alternative point-of-view. When I finish reading them and watch the films again, I'm sure I'll have a completely different experience and understand even better the classic dilemma between books and film adaptations.
Kal-yawn-am
Would you really want to get married in front of the cabinets of 10 states and 2 Union Territories, one national cabinet, the casts of 5 multistarrers and assorted junta (both civilian and military ruling) ? If you would, consider being born into the household of the Sahara Shri (that sounds more like a bodybuilding title, to be honest).I hope the younger Roys aren't anything like Augustus Fink-Nottle, whose nuptials caused him grave stress & exhalation. If they are, then they are in for trouble. At most wedding receptions, the broom-and-ride have a torrid time meeting hordes of people, shaking hands, nodding heads, smiling and receiving "Best Wishes from Mr. X and fly.". I have been a strong advocate for the use of modern technology such as flash cards and smiling mukhautas (a wonderful Russian storybook called Captains' Island had a female villain with a fake smile pasted on her lips) which may prevent the h(m)arried couple from being permanently disfigured and disabled. Fathers have to cop much of the blame, for they love to introduce all and sundry to the kids - they don't apply a filtering process. They have no pecking order, no list of most-wanted. They try to be egalitarian and introduce everyone who shows up. "This is my aunt's brother's third cousin". "Oh ho! You must meet him. He is the guy who didn't show me three answers in our XIIth Board exam, as a result of which I got into Engineering and not Medical".
The point I'm trying to make here is that I hope the Senior Shri is more considerate on this ground to his sons and dottirs-in-law-to-be, but having invited such dignitaries, he's gotta make sure he gets everyone on stage according to protocol. Even then, greeting ministers of every description is bound to take its toll. The Union Minister for Information Technology is ok, but having to shake hands with the Madhya Pradesh Minister for Animal Husbandry and Cow Protection is a little too much. I'd make sure the latter washes his hands first.
Don't even get me started on the phillumy guests. The rumour is that Karan Johar might shoot his next two multistarrers in three days in the scenic locales of the Sheher, for where else can you get these guys under one roof in the same block of dates? Rajkumar Santoshi bagged the contract for shooting the wedding videos, it is reported. That's quite a leg up for wedding video cameramen all around the country. Once Santoshi gets this entered into IMDB, the Union of W.V.C will make a collective representation to IMDB for inclusion of their credits, and to the I & B Ministry for the inception of a National Award in their category. Gone are the days when W.V.C would pan to catch the bride and her pretty companions, and the odd shot of an uncle easing a finger into his nasal cavities. Wedding Videos invariably left out recalcitrant relatives who would complain later that they never got to even one of the shots. Are they telecasting this wedding live on the Sahara channels? Will the guests wear the Sahara uniform with symbol pinned over their hearts like the newsreaders? Ooh, I'm all agog!
And is that why Bryan Adams was/is in the country? For the sangeet ceremony?
Ring and the King
Ticked off The Return of the King yesterday from the to-view list, and I did come back rather disappointed. It's strictly average, me thought. True, some of the battle sequences were stunningly created, but at the completion of the film, I was just tired. Perhaps it was because I haven't read the books (wanted to hold off till I finished watching all three), but I think they would've been more captivating. My perceptions are coloured by the end of the film being stretched for atleast 15 minutes - everyone in the theatre just lost it at the endless extensions into the future. Guess it's not easy to adapt a sprawling set of fiction.Was I the only one to see parallels in the screenplay of both the last installments of The Return of the King and The Matrix Revolutions in how there were three very similarly structured threads? One, the main force fighting a seemingly losing battle, the second being a small force bringing succour to the main force from an alternative and difficult route, and the third being the main protagonists moving towards the "source" through difficult terrain and the elements for sacrifice and doubt et al. Very similar to me. Of course, both exhibited a benumbing array of characters (real and fictional) to fill the screen. Gollum's characterization and presentation was keenly detailed as before. That was done very well. Perhaps, my movie watching habits are veering in the direction of more dialogue and less action based films. Still, I liked the Fellowship of the Ring the best. And please don't tell me LOTR-ROTK will win an Oscar! (that is, for Best Pic) I really agree with one BBC film reporter who hoped someone else would beat the force of the reel Ring. I don't think this must've been the best film of the year, and that the direction was top notch (I'm strictly talking in terms of Part III). But everyone's being "oh-so-inevitable" about it, so don't rule out a result similar to Spielberg & E.T at the Oscars (in 1981, IIRC).
The Aussie selectors have always exhibited some sort of perverse pleasure in dropping big names - it may serve to show the rest of the world their reserves and non-reliance on the aces. Though one is faithful to one's favourites, the Aussie selectors have got it right more often than not. Dean Jones mentioned the rumour that Warne would probably not be picked for the tour to Sri Lanka in response to Bhogle's comment that Warne would walk into it, especially given the troubled Indian series for their bowlers. It reflects the opposing positions of the romantic and the hardened pro - the romantics would love to see as much of Warne and his ilk for some more time.
Grab me a Grammy
Not being much of a Western music (especially pop) follower, The Grammies usually held only quizzing significance to me. Partially, I attribute it to the fact that there are so many of them to hand out, much like the Olympic golds for swimming. It's easier to remember the top Oscar categories, or the sprint golds, but when you have categories like Best New Male Country and 4 x 400 medley among many other similarly titled prizes, it is excusable to be washed away with the flotsam.Many "performers" win more than one awards - this seems to be a manifestation of the Pigeonhole Principle: there seem to be more awards than people wanting to win them, so it's obvious a few of them will take home a clutch.
But the Grammies do push a limit or two - they seem to have categories for anything that can be done with an open mouth (well, alright, almost anything!). Take Best Spoken Word for example. This year's winners included Bill Clinton and Mikhail Gorbachev. Given that Hillary Clinton won a Grammy some time back in a similar category, they're just waiting for Chelsea to say something into a tape, so as to complete the family album. But seriously, how Best can Clinton's Spoken Words get? His UnSpoken Words would be more interesting. And Gorbachev? Did they understand what he was saying? I cannot see how Bill and Mike can speak better than Pu La or Solomon Poppayya (I know I've got the spelling wrong there), but then we shouldn't kid ourselves that these are international awards.
Intransitive
A Transitive relation is one in which if an element "a" is related to element "b", and element "b" in turn is related to element "c", then "a" is also related to "c".Cricket definitely does not exhibit the transitive property. Or else, if people think Sachin Tendulkar plays like Don Bradman, and Virender Sehwag plays like Tendulkar, wouldn't that make Sehwag play like Bradman?
"Leave 'em alone!"
The title of this post would be my response to the many detractors of the Indian cricket team. Results have not gone our way, but they have gone exactly according to reason. Which is good. Indian cricket always suffers from the flash-in-the-pan success story that flatters its supporters. Let the fans learn the hard route to setting expectations that don't conceal a sting.Two men spent some time, during the collapse of the Indian innings at Sydney, talking about the series in its entirety and where it left Indian cricket. Both Harsha Bhogle and Dean Jones made the point that this series runs the danger of being judged by the last four games, which would wrongly erase the achievements in the months preceding that week. Jones thinks that this current Aussie team, whatever its performance against India in the Tests, is the best *ever* ODI team in the history of the game. Jones is not one given to tossing compliments lightly, also he is one of the true greats of the limited overs game, and among those from Simpson's lot that charted out a separate approach to this format - so one has to take his comments seriously. It is hard to argue with his statement - rarely has a team played so mightily in all departments as this team. Which is why let us wait before passing judgement on our home team. It's hard to say where we stand - I agree with Harish they're not number 2 yet. Maybe three or even four. For me, the real test will be what India does in the next 12 months against various other countries.
Of the many finals India has lost, I guess half of them have been to Australia? If so, and if we argue Australia are playing astonishingly well, the best ODI cricket ever, then don't weigh those defeats as much as losing to any other team. The only other times we've lost were to South Africa and West Indies, I think. And that was some time ago. This doesn't clearly show where we stand on an absolute scale, especially because in the last few months, India has been constantly playing Australia, New Zealand and Zimbabwe. Results against Zimbabwe & NZ are skewed indicators, the former are half a team in reality and the latter were played met on strange wickets there and here. We play Australia again in the next 12 months, but we also play other tournaments - against Pakistan, England & the Champions Trophy. Those would be better indications as to where we really stand. Till then, don't exaggerate or demean the standing of the team.
People who complain India loses in finals forget that we hardly made finals 3-4 years ago. Would they rather have India bowing out before the knockout stages or India losing at finals? Atleast the latter means that the team is playing worse than just 1 of the participating teams - usually it has been Australia, and that is a fact. I agree that their showing in finals has resulted in demoralising losses, but compared to the team of 4 years ago, this team is winning more matches. Also, we now know that the team has about 5-7 players who can put in top performances - 4 years ago, that number was 1 or perhaps 2. Don't forget that we're still not a well-oiled machine rolling in unison - we commit a lot of basic errors - so don't expect them to be world champs yet. Not until they can show they know how to do those things better than the current world champs. That's why I don't have any bitterness or moroseness - inspite of my optimism, I had no real reason to expect them to outperform the team that's playing better than anyone else has in the history of the game.
There are a host of immediate problems: keepers, spinners, Dravid unable to play his Bevan-like role like he did in the World-Cup, the obvious technical faults of Ganguly, the mental fears of Tendulkar, the stop-start performances of Yuvraj. There are pluses too - 5 medium pacers to choose from, a possible bowling all-rounder in Pathan, terrific catching, the wicket-taking abilities of Agarkar, the indications that there are a lot of runs left in Tendulkar & Dravid, and Laxman's realisation that he may actually have things to do in an ODI match. One thing I must say is - the senior players need to have a long think about their place in history - it is there for the taking, but they seemed to be filled with unknown trepidations in their journey towards it. The next 5 years beckon - they will decide India's cricketing future like never before.
India are in serious trouble of becoming the 2000s equivalent of the England team of the 80s - which got into a lot of finals and had some great individual talent, but never managed to win a single important trophy. This cannot be attributed to "choking" - the finals they lost were never manoeuvred by England into winning positions (except perhaps the '87 WC final). They never looked like winning. For me, "choking" is to contrive to lose from positions of victory. Gavaskar says this Indian team has taken the tag of chokers from the South Africans. I disagree. South Africa invented newer ways to lose from winning positions - like Boucher/Pollock in the '03 WC, and Klusener/Donald in the previous edition. Also, they did so in various stages of a tournament. This Indian team looks like the Englishmen of Gatting and Gooch - they don't know how to get into winning positions in the first place. Incidentally, unless Saurav Ganguly does a repair job as an all-round player, he could end up being the Brearley of India. For a start, he could re-invent himself as a fielder like Sidhu did.
History may repeat itself, but it's not necessary that the repetition will be a clone of the past - minor mutations are possible. It is equally possible that India learn from these victories and defeats to go on to illustrious deeds. Tendulkar gives the impression that he is playing out two cricket lives in one - the newest one has just begun. And Rahul Dravid - please tell your teammates to hold on to the memories of losing and to do everything possible to not face that feeling again.
Dousing the Fire
Maybe it was the illustrious company of fellow BC Quizzer and one of the Chakravyuuh (COEP's own open quiz) organizers, Anup Mankar, but together we may have cracked one of the many annoying puzzles of recent Bollywood titles. If you're among one of those who likes to keep a close eye on titles of the form X the Y, you would know one of the earliest and most famous was Daag the Fire. Everyone thought this was an awful piece of translation from Hindi to English. But fikar not, here is an implausible theory for it.Anup told me about the impending meeting with Dr. AAG, a high ranking PIET official (let it be said that samajhdaar ko ishaara ...), on the matter of the quiz. The natural response to someone saying aag was to expand it and say Oh, you mean Aag the Fire? And then, like a firebolt gone astray, it hit us: the makers must have started off with The Aag the Fire which some enterprising sub-editor somewhere contracted, for lack of space, into the now notorious Daag the Fire.
For more of the same (what some Tamil speakers would call "veTTi pech.u"), please visit the Boat Club quizzes, Saturdays at 12 noon. No wonder that the senior Mankar thinks his youngest-born is wasting his time on weekends.)