Watching 'Black Friday'
Anurag Kashyap must be a slightly happy man. One out (but not down) and some more to go. His little bright toddler, Black Friday, is out. Paanch, one fears, is growing up to become a bitter and angry adolescent. All these kids want to do first is to be able to come out. Then play with the other kids. Perhaps others will call them ugly and poor. But let them not become bitter without experiencing a moment of sunshine.Like every self-respecting "good film" watcher, I had seen the bootleg version of the film and keenly anticipated the release. So went to make contribution to the Anurag Kashyap appreciation fund (as Samrat termed it). Hanging out at a local multiplex, waiting for Samrat and his wife, I saw a poster of "Black Friday" from a distance. Hanging upside down. A little burst of anger surged. Took it as a sign of callousness on part of the 'plex. Typical, one thought. Closer inspection. "This is not a mistake! We're crazy" said a sign on top. Smiles around.
The good news for those who've seen the circulated version on their PCs: there are several additional sequences in the film. The slightly bad news: the film seems a little long. Not unwieldy though, but just too long. The 2 hours print seen earlier seemed taut and precise. The Indian release, however, covers the entire book's scope (adding sequences about the landings, more on Dawood's - still a shadowy figure - involvement, and Tiger's immediate provocations in the pre-blast riots.)
What the film also does is further blast to smithereens the roof that conceals Hindi filmdom's underbelly, revealing a set of wonderful actors who have no place in sunny-side-up "Bollywood" (a term which I use pejoratively, of course). It's been a while since Satya that one saw a solid ensemble put together, whose business is not to strut about but merely to inhabit and exist in four dimensions.
Introspecting about the film, Kashyap wonders whether he's succeeded in his efforts at making a "necessary film" that will kindle self-debate in the minds of the watcher. Judging by reactions in the theatre, I'm pessimistic about this. For, like some of my experiences before, I heard people laugh at many of the wrong places. What excites laughter during a tense interrogation scene or when someone's being ripped apart or just merely hearing expletives? Does the director expect to hear laughter at these points? Does the audience let him down? Have they been weaned on a different cinematic diet? These questions always puzzle me.
In the end, the plug. Go watch "Black Friday". In a theatre. It's worth your time and money. God Promise. (And while you're at it, read S. Hussain Zaidi's book too.)
5 comments:
couldnt share the same feeling about junta laughing at the wrong places more!!!
wonder if it's a deliberate attempt on Kashyap's part to lighten up things a little, or is it that we expect to be humored even in a supposedly grim fare like black friday..
you and i can never tell...
http://madness-of-madras.blogspot.com/2007/02/good-friday.html
http://madness-of-madras.blogspot.com/2007/02/dor-darshan.html
Not watched Black Friday (yet), but the phenomenon (of people laughing at the wrong times) probably can be ascribed to discomfort.
BTW, Nice blogs(!)
(sree)
Thanks for dropping by, Sree. Perhaps it could be 'discomfort'.
I quite admired the risk Kashyap took by making it documentary-style and doing it without a 'hero'. Reminds one of Scorsese, but IMO, much better than him or Ramgopal in not just looking at the underworld chappies.
Oh yes, the laughing-in-the-wrong-places-syndrome makes me wonder if these chaps even understand the basic premise of the movie - I saw copious quantities of giggling-and-laughing in, of all movies, Nishabd.
Sometimes, I worry that with audiences like these, the few intelligently made movies that there are these days will end up being commercial failures. One hopes not.
Shamanth
shamanth: I also liked the appropriate use of the "chapter" format. Given the intricate strands happening simultaneously, this was a very good way of presenting the story.
As for audiences, well, every Dhoom-2 explodes the belief that audiences can reject vaporous drivel.
Post a Comment